Fall 2022 Syllabus
Section 001
CRN: 10659
MWF 12:00 — 12:50 PM
Edith Kanaka‘ole Hall 111
Hybrid Instruction
Dr. Timothy J. Freeman
The University of Hawaii at Hilo
Edith Kanaka‘ole Hall 212
office: 932-7479; cell: 345-5231
freeman@hawaii.edu
Office Hours: MWF 1:00-2:00 PM
and by appointment
Phil 329 Environmental Ethics
Central ethical questions concerning the natural world, including environmental justice, responding to climate change and environmental devastation, and the relationship between human beings and the environment.
Reflecting on Nature: Readings in Environmental Ethics and Philosophy, 2nd. Ed. Lori Gruen, Dale Jamieson & Chistopher Schlottmann, Oxford University Press, 2013.
This course will provide an in-depth introduction to the field of environmental ethics. The course will cover a range of issues including the relationship between the human and nonhuman world, whether or not nonhuman nature has inherent rights, the problems posed by climate change, the decline of biodiversity, the loss of wilderness, the production of food, overpopulation, economic policy and globalization. We will examine a number of key texts in the development of environmental ethics.
[Philosophy courses for GE purposes]: (As with all Philosophy courses) Students who successfully complete the course will be able to:
●respond clearly, logically and critically to examination questions and discussion questions about some important philosophical issues relevant to the course;
●read, comprehend, and discuss philosophical texts relevant to the course;
●compose effective written materials that assimilate, synthesize and reflect on course information;
●identify and describe in writing and in class discussion some important aspects of the cultural heritage and contributions of Environmental ethics.
This class is designated as a Hybrid Course. According to the UH Hilo Designation of Types of Courses this means:
"There will be a mix of face-to-face and online instruction. The instructor determines when students will attend face-to-face (in the classroom, laboratory, and/or field experience). Students are expected to attend face-to-face sessions as required by the Instructor."
UH Hilo Designation of Types of Courses
Students are encouraged to tune in to the synchronous sessions and encouraged to turn video cameras on so that you can see each other for better class time discussions.
Attendance and Participation (10%):
Philosophy comes alive and most interesting through discussion, through engaging with each other about questions raised in the texts. Beginning the third week of the course there will be a weekly symposium in which we discuss the readings for the week. Please attend these discussions with your name visible when you log on to Zoom and your video cameras on. Each student will be expected to help lead at least two of the weekly discussions.
Mid-Term essay assignment (40% each)
A 4-5 page essay.
Final Term Paper (50%)
The final term paper should be 6-8 pages in length.
Grading will be determined according to the following scale:
A 95-100 Excellent
A - 90-94
B + 87-89
B 84-86 Good
B - 80-83
C + 77-79
C 74-76 Satisfactory
C - 70-73 Poor
D 60-70 Failure
F below 60
Current, up to date statements regarding ITS, Disability Services, Advising, Academic Integrity, Kilohana Academic Success, Student Conduct, Mental Health, Students of Concern, and Title IX/EEO can be found at the following links:
Short Link
Mobile link
Course Introduction & Orientation
Introduction to Environmental Ethics
The Climate Catastrophe and the Mālama Honua Worldwide Voyage
Powerpoint presentation
“Can a Collapse of Global Civilization be Avoided?”
Paul R. Ehrlich and Anne H. Ehrlich
Symposium
Anthropocentrism
The Historical Roots of Our Ecological Crisis, Lynn White Jr.
Readings from Lynn White, Jr., Genesis, Aristotle, Locke
(Reflecting on Nature: 1-16)
*August 30: Last day to register to add classes and to withdraw from courses without owing tuition*
Anthropocentrism Readings
Film: Before the Flood
Symposium
*Holiday: Labor Day*
Nonanthropocentrism
Readings from Darwin, Muir, Leopold, Thoreau, Mill, Botkin, Shiva, Gould, Plumwood, Naess, and Carson
(Reflecting on Nature: 17-37)
*September 9: Last day to exercise Credit/No Credit
and final deadline to apply for Spring 2021 Graduation*
Theories of Environmental Ethics
Readings from Routley, Williams, Goodpaster,
(Reflecting on Nature: 38-72)
*September 13: Last day to drop a class online without a "W"
and last day to receive 50% refund for complete withdrawals.*
Theories of Environmental Ethics
Readings from Elliot & Sandler
(Reflecting on Nature: 57-72)
Egalitarian Biocentrism
"The Ethics of Respect for Nature," Paul W. Taylor
(Reflecting on Nature: 72-81)
Hierarchical Biocentrism
"Persons in Nature: Toward an Applicable and Unified Environmental Ethics," Frederick Ferré
Symposium
"The Land Ethic," Aldo Leopold
The Land Ethic
Short video by philosopher Douglas Borcoman
Aldo Leopold: Learning from the Land
PBS Wisconsin Documentary
Aldo Leopold: Prophet for all Seasons
PBS Wisconsin Documentary
[From] Beyond the Land Ethic, J. Baird Callicott
(Reflecting on Nature: 72-89)
Conversations around the Green Fire
Interview with J.Baird Callicott
Symposium
"One Community," Peter Singer
(Reflecting on Nature: 93-108)
[From] "Sustainability and Intergenerational Justice," Brian Barry
"Environmental Racism," Sheila Foster and Luke Cole
(Reflecting on Nature: 109-139)
Symposium
"All Animals are Equal," Peter Singer
(Reflecting on Nature: 140-150)
"The Moral Status of Animals," Lori Gruen
(Reflecting on Nature: 151-160)
Symposium
Mid-Term Essay Assignment
Due Monday, October 24
"The Heart of Deep Ecology," Andrew McLaughlin
Symposium
Symposium
*October 31: Last day to drop a class online with a "W"*
Symposium
Heidegger and Environmental Philosophy
"The Question Concerning Technology"
Heidegger and Environmental Philosophy
The Meaning of Being – Understanding Terrence Malick
* Holiday: Veteran's Day*
“The Ecological Crisis as a Crisis of Agriculture,” Wendell Berry
Eating Animals, Jonathan Safran Foer
"The Omnivore's Delusion: Against the Agri-intellectuals," Blake Hurst
The Ethics of What We Eat, Peter Singer and Jim Mason
(Reflecting on Nature: 184-192)
"Eating Meat and Eating People," Cora Diamond
"Meat and Morality: Alternatives to Factory Farming," Evelyn Pluhar
(Reflecting on Nature: 192-201)
Film
Food Choices
Population Growth
"An Essay on the Principle of Population," Thomas Robert Malthus
"The Tragedy of the Commons," Garrett Hardin
Population Growth
"A Special Moment in History," Bill McKibben
* Non-Instructional Day*
Environmental Ethics and Economics
"A Declaration of Sustainability," Paul Hawken
"The Steady-State Economy," Herman E. Daly
Economics
"Making Capitalism Sustainable," John Elkington
[From] This Changes Everything: Capitalism vs the Climate, Naomi Klein
Introduction
Chapter 2
The Climate Catastrophe and the Mālama Honua Worldwide Voyage
Tim Freeman
Conflict on Maunakea: For Whom are the Stars
Tim Freeman
Film:
Koyaanisqatsi
The Enduring Magnetism of Koyaanisqatsi
(Documentary on the film)
Symposium
The final exam is the Term Paper, due by the of the exam period.
**Schedule is subject to revision**
Made in RapidWeaver